Grace's baptism book

It's so weird to say, but the time has come for me to work on Grace's baptism book!!  She is turning eight next year, and with our new baby coming, I really feel like I need to get started on it.  One of the photo's that I needed to take was for "A is for Accountability".  The photo of the birthday cake I used for Morgan's book was totally not what I had in mind, so I decided on THIS.  I can't decide between these 2 photographs, but I think either one will work great.  What do YOU think?

Do you like this one?

Or this.....